[Excerpted from: Albrecht, Katherine. "Supermarket Cards: The Tip of the Retail Surveillance Iceberg." Denver University Law Review, Volume 79, Issue 4, pp. 534-539 and 558-565.]
"In 5-10 years, whole new ways of doing things will emerge and gradually become commonplace. Expect big changes." 1 - MIT's Auto-ID Center
Supermarket cards and retail surveillance devices are merely the opening volley of the marketers' war against consumers. If consumers fail to oppose these practices now, our long-term prospects may look like something from a dystopian science fiction novel.
A new consumer goods tracking system called Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) is poised to enter all of our lives, with profound implications for consumer privacy. RFID couples radio frequency (RF) identification technology with highly miniaturized computers that enable products to be identified and tracked at any point along the supply chain. 2
The system could be applied to almost any physical item, from ballpoint pens to toothpaste, which would carry their own unique information in the form of an embedded chip. 3 The chip sends out an identification signal allowing it to communicate with reader devices and other products embedded with similar chips. 4
Analysts envision a time when the system will be used to identify and track every item produced on the planet. 5
A number for every item on the planet
RFID employs a numbering scheme called EPC (for "electronic product code") which can provide a unique ID for any physical object in the world. 6 The EPC is intended to replace the UPC bar code used on products today. 7
Unlike the bar code, however, the EPC goes beyond identifying product categories--it actually assigns a unique number to every single item that rolls off a manufacturing line. 8 For example, each pack of cigarettes, individual can of soda, light bulb or package of razor blades produced would be uniquely identifiable through its own EPC number. 9
Once assigned, this number is transmitted by a radio frequency ID tag (RFID) in or on the product. 10 These tiny tags, predicted by some to cost less than 1 cent each by 2004, 11 are "somewhere between the size of a grain of sand and a speck of dust." 12 They are to be built directly into food, clothes, drugs, or auto-parts during the manufacturing process. 13
Receiver or reader devices are used to pick up the signal transmitted by the RFID tag. Proponents envision a pervasive global network of millions of receivers along the entire supply chain -- in airports, seaports, highways, distribution centers, warehouses, retail stores, and in the home. 14 This would allow for seamless, continuous identification and tracking of physical items as they move from one place to another, 15 enabling companies to determine the whereabouts of all their products at all times. 16
Steven Van Fleet, an executive at International Paper, looks forward to the prospect. "We'll put a radio frequency ID tag on everything that moves in the North American supply chain," he enthused recently. 17
The ultimate goal is for RFID to create a "physically linked world" 18 in which every item on the planet is numbered, identified, catalogued, and tracked. And the technology exists to make this a reality. Described as "a political rather than a technological problem," creating a global system "would . . . involve negotiation between, and consensus among, different countries." 19 Supporters are aiming for worldwide acceptance of the technologies needed to build the infrastructure within the next few years. 20
The implications of RFID
"Theft will be drastically reduced because items will report when they are stolen, their smart tags also serving as a homing device toward their exact location." 21 - MIT's Auto-ID Center
Since the Auto-ID Center's founding at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in 1999, it has moved forward at remarkable speed. The center has attracted funding from some of the largest consumer goods manufacturers in the world, and even counts the Department of Defense among its sponsors. 22 In a mid-2001 pilot test with Gillette, Philip Morris, Procter & Gamble, and Wal-Mart, the center wired the entire city of Tulsa, Oklahoma with radio-frequency equipment to verify its ability to track RFID equipped packages. 23
Though many RFID proponents appear focused on inventory and supply chain efficiency, others are developing financial and consumer applications that, if adopted, will have chilling effects on consumers' ability to escape the oppressive surveillance of manufacturers, retailers, and marketers. Of course, government and law enforcement will be quick to use the technology to keep tabs on citizens, as well.
The European Central Bank is quietly working to embed RFID tags in the fibers of Euro banknotes by 2005. 24 The tag would allow money to carry its own history by recording information about where it has been, thus giving governments and law enforcement agencies a means to literally "follow the money" in every transaction. 25 If and when RFID devices are embedded in banknotes, the anonymity that cash affords in consumer transactions will be eliminated.
Hitachi Europe wants to supply the tags. The company has developed a smart tag chip that--at just 0.3mm square and as thin as a human hair -- can easily fit inside of a banknote. 26 Mass-production of the new chip will start within a year. 27
Consumer marketing applications will decimate privacy
"Radio frequency is another technology that supermarkets are already using in a number of places throughout the store. We now envision a day where consumers will walk into a store, select products whose packages are embedded with small radio frequency UPC codes, and exit the store without ever going through a checkout line or signing their name on a dotted line." 28
Jacki Snyder, Manager of Electronic Payments for Supervalu (Supermarkets), Inc., and Chair, Food Marketing Institute Electronic Payments Committee
RFID would expand marketers' ability to monitor individuals' behavior to undreamt of extremes. With corporate sponsors like Wal-Mart, Target, the Food Marketing Institute, Home Depot, and British supermarket chain Tesco, as well as some of the world's largest consumer goods manufacturers including Procter and Gamble, Phillip Morris, and Coca Cola 29 it may not be long before RFID-based surveillance tags begin appearing in every store-bought item in a consumer's home.
According to a video tour of the "Home of the Future" and "Store of the Future" sponsored by Procter and Gamble, applications could include shopping carts that automatically bill consumers' accounts (cards would no longer be needed to link purchases to individuals), refrigerators that report their contents to the supermarket for re-ordering, and interactive televisions that select commercials based on the contents of a home's refrigerator. 30
Now that shopper cards have whetted their appetite for data, marketers are no longer content to know who buys what, when, where, and how. As incredible as it may seem, they are now planning ways to monitor consumers' use of products within their very homes. RFID tags coupled with indoor receivers installed in shelves, floors, and doorways, 31 could provide a degree of omniscience about consumer behavior that staggers the imagination.
Consider the following statements by John Stermer, Senior Vice President of eBusiness Market Development at ACNielsen:
"[After bar codes] [t]he next 'big thing' [was] [f]requent shopper cards. While these did a better job of linking consumers and their purchases, loyalty cards were severely limited...consider the usage, consumer demographic, psychographic and economic blind spots of tracking data.... [S]omething more integrated and holistic was needed to provide a ubiquitous understanding of on- and off-line consumer purchase behavior, attitudes and product usage. The answer: RFID (radio frequency identification) technology.... In an industry first, RFID enables the linking of all this product information with a specific consumer identified by key demographic and psychographic markers....Where once we collected purchase information, now we can correlate multiple points of consumer product purchase with consumption specifics such as the how, when and who of product use." 32
Marketers aren't the only ones who want to watch what you do in your home. Enter again the health surveillance connection. Some have suggested that pill bottles in medicine cabinets be tagged with RFID devices to allow doctors to remotely monitor patient compliance with prescriptions. 33
While developers claim that RFID technology will create "order and balance" in a chaotic world, 34 even the center's executive director, Kevin Ashton, acknowledges there's a "Brave New World" feel to the technology. 35 He admits, for example, that people might balk at the thought of police using RFID to scan the contents of a car's trunk without needing to open it. 36 The Center's co-director, Sanjay E. Sarma, has already begun planning strategies to counter the public backlash he expects the system will encounter. 37
References:
Note: This overview is an excerpt from the article, "Supermarket Cards: Tip of the Retail Surveillance Iceberg," published by the Denver University Law Review, 79(4), Summer 2002 edition. All associated footnotes and references found online were available May 2002 and original documentation is archived at the Denver University Law Review editorial office. A PDF of the entire article can be obtained by written request to Katherine Albrecht, "kma @/at nocards.org."
1 Auto-ID Center Questions, accessed online May, 2002 at http://www.autoidcenter.org/questions19.asp
2 Greg Jacobson, "Technology revolution underway." Chain Drug Review, October 22, 2001. Available online at http://www.chaindrugreview.com/articles/tech_revolution.html
3 Auto Center Joins UK Group, MIT TECH TALK, (Jan. 24, 2001), available at http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/tt/2001/jan24/auto.html
4 Introduction to Auto-ID, available at http://www.autoidcenter.org/technology.asp
5 The Electronic Product Code (EPC), available at http://www.eretailnews.com/Features/0105epc1.htm
6 Steve Traiman, Tag, You're It! The EPC Tag Could Revolutionize the Retail Supply Chain, Retail Systems Reseller (November 2001) available at http://www.retailsystemsreseller.com/archive/Nov01/Nov01_5.shtml
7 See EPC, supra note 5.
8 Id.
9 Steve Traiman, Tag, You're It! The EPC Tag Could Revolutionize the Retail Supply Chain, Retail Systems Reseller (November 2001) available at http://www.retailsystemsreseller.com/archive/Nov01/Nov01_5.shtml
10 Margie Semilof, Bar Codes in a Chip, InternetWeek.com (Nov. 19, 2001), available at http://www.internetweek.com/newslead01/lead111901.htm
11 Lisa Roner, T2T -The Next Wave of the Internet Revolution, Eyeforpharma, available at http://www.eyeforpharma.com/index.asp?news=2822 (n.d.)
12 Semilof, supra note 10
13 Robin Cover, Auto-ID Center Uses Physical Markup Language in Radio Frequency Identification (RF ID) Tag Technology, The XML Cover Pages (Nov. 21, 2001), available at http://xml.coverpages.org/ni2001-11-21-c.html
14 Cheryl Rosen & Mathew G. Nelson, The Fast Track: Radio-frequency Devices Promise to Make it Easier to Monitor the Flow of Inventory Across the Supply Chain, INFORMATIONWEEK (June 18, 2001), available at http://www.informationweek.com/shared/printableArticle?doc_id=IWK200106…; see also Charles W. Schmidt, The Networked Physical World, available at http://www.rand.org/scitech/stpi/ourfuture/Internet/sec4_networked.html (last visited Apr. 5, 2002); Indrani Rajkhowa, Shopping Gets Smarter, COMPUTERSTODAY (June 16-30, 2001), available at http://www.india-today.com/ctoday/20010616/marvels.html
15 Cover, supra note 13
16 Charles W. Schmidt, The Networked Physical World, available at http://www.rand.org/scitech/stpi/ourfuture/Internet/sec4_networked.html
17 Lori Valigra, Smart Tags: Shopping Will Never Be the Same, CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR (Mar. 29, 2001), available at http://www.csmonitor.com/durable/2001/03/29/fp13s1-csm.shtml
18 M.K. Shankar, Algorithm Ensures Unique Object ID, NIKKEI ELECTRONICS ASIA (Apr. 2001), available at http://www.nikkeibp.asiabiztech.com/nea/200104/inet_127161.html
19 Id.
20 Id.
21 Auto-ID Center, Applications, available at http://www.autoidcenter.org/technology_applications.asp
22 Auto-ID Center, Sponsor Companies, available at http://www.autoidcenter.org/sponsors_companies.asp
23 Cheryl Rosen & Mathew G. Nelson, The Fast Track: Radio-frequency Devices Promise to Make it Easier to Monitor the Flow of Inventory Across the Supply Chain, INFORMATIONWEEK (June 18, 2001), available at http://www.informationweek.com/shared/printableArticle?doc_id=IWK200106…
24 Junko Yoshida, Euro Bank Notes to Embed RFID Chips by 2005, EETIMES (Dec. 19, 2001), available at http://www.eetimes.com/story/OEG20011219S0016
25 Id.
26 George Cole, The Little Label with an Explosion of Applications, FIN. TIMES (Jan. 15, 2002), available at http://news.ft.com/ft/gx.cgi/ftc?pagename=View&c=Article&cid=FT30414MGWC
27 Id.
28 Testimony before the U.S. House of Representatives, Tuesday September 19th, 2000. Subcommittee on Domestic and International Monetary Policy, Committee on Banking and Financial Services, Washington, DC. Available online at: http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/bank/hba66988.000/hba66988_0.HTM#68
29 (SUPRA Note above) Auto-ID website Auto-ID Center, Sponsor Companies, available at http://www.autoidcenter.org/sponsors_companies.asp
30 Kayte VanScoy, Can the Internet Hot-Wire P&G?: They Know What You Eat, ZIFF DAVIS SMART BUSINESS (Jan. 1, 2001), available at http://www.smartbusinessmag.com/article/0,3668,a=13216,00.asp
31 Cover, supra note 13.
32 John Stermer, Radio Frequency ID: A New Era for Marketers? CONSUMER INSIGHT MAGAZINE (Winter 2001), available at http://acnielsen.com/pubs/ci/2001/q4/features/radio.htm
33 Schmidt, supra note 16
34 Auto-ID Center available at http://www.autoidcenter.org/applications.asp
35 VanScoy, supra note 30
36 David Orenstein, Raising the Bar, BUSINESS 2.0 (Aug. 2000), available at http://www.business2.com/articles/mag/0,1640,13975|3,FF.html
37 Indrani Rajkhowa, Shopping Gets Smarter, COMPUTERSTODAY (June 16-30, 2001), available at http://www.india-today.com/ctoday/20010616/marvels.html
by Katherine Albrecht, CASPIAN